Comparing Google's Guided Learning to ChatGPT's Study Mode: Which excels?
AI Tools Transform the Classroom of the Future
In the near future, students may find themselves learning alongside artificial intelligence (AI) tools like ChatGPT and Google's Guided Learning. These innovative platforms are designed to reshape self-paced, personalised education, offering a unique blend of flexibility and structure to cater to various learning styles.
OpenAI's Study Mode, integrated into ChatGPT, serves as a digital study buddy for interactive, question-based learning. This text-based tool refuses to provide direct answers and instead encourages learners to develop understanding through questions, hints, and iterative feedback. The text-based nature of OpenAI's Study Mode can be enhanced with GPT-4o, which can handle visuals and voice.
On the other hand, Google's Guided Learning offers a more structured, visual, and lesson-like experience. This feature, based on Google's Gemini, delivers content in structured modules, including definitions, visual diagrams, real-world examples, and checkpoint quizzes. Google's Guided Learning is less chatty than ChatGPT and offers a more organized experience for visual learners or those who prefer bite-sized lessons with clear goals.
The key differences between ChatGPT's Study Mode and Google's Guided Learning primarily lie in their learning styles and approaches. ChatGPT Study Mode emphasises a learner-driven, dialogic process that fosters critical thinking through interactive questioning and feedback, while Google’s Guided Learning relies on structured, linear pathways providing content and assessments to ensure skill mastery in a controlled setting.
In Google's Guided Learning, students can learn about topics step-by-step with motion diagrams, animations, and short quizzes to test understanding. Students can also ask questions and request quizzes in OpenAI's Study Mode, which recalibrates in real time.
Google is integrating Guided Learning into its broader education push, offering free Gemini Pro access for students and investing $1 billion in AI-powered learning tools. This move aims to provide a new learning experience for students, offering visual explanations, built-in progress tracking, and feeling more like an online course or an upgraded Khan Academy module.
Both OpenAI's Study Mode and Google's Guided Learning aim to serve as digital study buddies, but cater to different learning styles. ChatGPT for interactive, question-based learning and Google for structured, visual learning. However, it is essential to remember that these AI tools are not intended to replace teachers but rather to reshape self-paced, personalised education and provide a new learning experience.
The classroom of the future will likely have an AI sitting right beside students, offering a blend of flexibility (ChatGPT) and structure (Guided Learning) to cater to various learning styles. This development promises to revolutionise education, making it more accessible, engaging, and effective for learners of all ages and backgrounds.
[1] OpenAI. (2023). ChatGPT Study Mode. [Online]. Available: https://www.openai.com/blog/chatgpt-study-mode/
[2] Google. (2023). Google Guided Learning. [Online]. Available: https://www.google.com/education/guided-learning/
[3] Google. (2023). Google's response to ChatGPT: Guided Learning. [Online]. Available: https://www.google.com/blog/product/education/googles-response-to-chatgpt-guided-learning/
[4] OpenAI. (2023). How ChatGPT Study Mode works. [Online]. Available: https://www.openai.com/blog/how-chatgpt-study-mode-works/
[5] OpenAI. (2023). ChatGPT Study Mode vs Google Guided Learning. [Online]. Available: https://www.openai.com/blog/chatgpt-study-mode-vs-google-guided-learning/
The unique aspects of OpenAI's Study Mode and Google's Guided Learning, integrated into AI tools like ChatGPT and Google's Guided Learning respectively, radically alter the approach to self-paced, personalised education. OpenAI's Study Mode focuses on learner-driven, dialogic processes, fostering critical thinking through interactive questioning and feedback, while Google's Guided Learning delivers structured, visual content through motion diagrams, animations, and quizzes. Despite these differences, both technologies aim to serve as digital study buddies, catering to various learning styles, but not replacing the importance of teachers in the classroom of the future.
